Think there was a post somewhere around which went something like 'how do we use "janakute" and "janai". I think ahochaude did explain it, like Sono koto Janai.. means that's not it? right?
So... I was listening in to a J song, and it went something like, "Hitori Janai"... so what does that mean? if i'm not wrong, 'hitori' means one person... is that right...
Joined: 23 Dec 2002 Posts: 319 Location: Singapore Country:
Posted: Mon Nov 03, 2003 8:37 pm Post subject:
not really sure about this but i *guess* janakute is used when you want to say something in addition after janakute in the sentence, and vice versa for janai?
So... are you guys saying that 'janai' is a negative term...? what i mean is, does it denote negative sentences? Like in the above examples,
Sono koto janai -- that's not it.
Hitori Janai -- not alone...
I notice both are negative sentences...
i'm still abit confused about this 'janai' thingy. anybody care to enlighten me further? More examples, if possible... and do explain if we can use them just about ANYTIME, anywhere. Thanks!!!
sorry, double post. what's happening.. when i click post i don't get a confirmation message... instead i get an error message. but the post still shows up...
erhh... mods plz delete this.
Last edited by velvet_ice on Mon Nov 03, 2003 8:57 pm; edited 1 time in total
Joined: 23 Dec 2002 Posts: 319 Location: Singapore Country:
Posted: Mon Nov 03, 2003 8:50 pm Post subject:
not really sure about this but i *guess* janakute is used when you want to say something in addition after janakute in the sentence, and vice versa for janai?
Joined: 01 Oct 2003 Posts: 10291 Location: Matsuhama-cho, Ashiya-shi, Hyogo-ken, Japan Country:
Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2003 2:38 am Post subject:
velvet_ice wrote:
So... are you guys saying that 'janai' is a negative term...? what i mean is, does it denote negative sentences? Like in the above examples,
Sono koto janai -- that's not it.
Hitori Janai -- not alone...
I notice both are negative sentences...
i'm still abit confused about this 'janai' thingy. anybody care to enlighten me further? More examples, if possible... and do explain if we can use them just about ANYTIME, anywhere. Thanks!!!
v_ice
"Janai" is a negative term. Take my username for example. Ahochaude. In Kansai-ben, it means I'm not an idiot/fool etc. Normally it would be "Ahojanai" (I'm not a idiot/fool)
If I had to put it in a way, I would say that "Janai" means "not".
One more example is "Ii janai" (Why not).
* "Tada janai" (It's not free)
* "Kanojo janai" (That's not my girlfriend)
* "AV janai" (It's not porn)
* "Sukebe janai" (I'm not a perv.)
* "Jyosei janai" (That's not a woman)
"Janai" is a negative term. Take my username for example. Ahochaude. In Kansai-ben, it means I'm not an idiot/fool etc. Normally it would be "Ahojanai" (I'm not a idiot/fool)
If I had to put it in a way, I would say that "Janai" means "not".
One more example is "Ii janai" (Why not).
* "Tada janai" (It's not free)
* "Kanojo janai" (That's not my girlfriend)
* "AV janai" (It's not porn)
* "Sukebe janai" (I'm not a perv.)
* "Jyosei janai" (That's not a woman)
Joined: 01 Oct 2003 Posts: 10291 Location: Matsuhama-cho, Ashiya-shi, Hyogo-ken, Japan Country:
Posted: Thu Nov 06, 2003 2:36 am Post subject:
velvet_ice wrote:
ah i c.... thanks for your help!
Sorry, I fogot that there are some cases in which you may need to apply the "nai" in differently. Anything thing that ends with "i" or "ii", you'll need to substitute "ku" in place of the "ja" before the "nai".
Example : "Samukunai" (It's not cold) *"Samui"- "Cold"
"Sabishiikunai" (Not lonely) *"Sabishii"- "Lonely"
"Hoshikunai" (I don't want) *"Hoshii"- "Want"
"Shitakunai" (I don't want to do) *"Shitai"- "Want to do"
"Yaritakunai" (I don't want to do) *"Yaru"- "Do"
"Atsukunai" (It's not hot) *"Atsui"- "Hot"
"Urusakunai" (It's not loud/irritating) *"Urusai"- "Loud/irritating
These are the cases in which the adjectives end in "i" or "ii" where you would put "ku" before the "nai" to create a negative sentence.
In the cases of verbs, you also apply the same rule ("ku" before "nai")
"Tabetakunai" (I don't want to eat)
"Nomitakunai" (I don't want to drink)
"Kikitakunai" (I don't want to listen/hear)
"Ikitakunai" (I don't want to go)
"Yomitakunai" (I don't want to read)
"Okitakunai" (I don't want to wake up)
"Mitakunai" (I don't want to see)
Pretty much in anything else, you may use the "janai" spoken of earlier.
Note: In dramas you'll probably hear something like "Mitakunee" or "Tabetakunee" etc. This is slang. (Ikebukuro West Gate Park especially) Just remember the basic rule of "nai" and when you hear "nee", you'll immediatley be able to understand what the speaker is trying to say. Slang or not.
I hope this extends your understanding on the topic a little bit more.
Last edited by ahochaude on Thu Nov 06, 2003 9:51 am; edited 1 time in total
hey ahochaude.. if you have the time, why don't you have japanese lessons on a certain of the week.. then we can learn more from you too..
Thanks ahochaude. I agree with arashinokoto. If you can spare the time that is. I feel really embarassed posting so many questions, and I'm kinda lost now ... dunno where to start learning. Guess I should start from scratch
Joined: 01 Oct 2003 Posts: 10291 Location: Matsuhama-cho, Ashiya-shi, Hyogo-ken, Japan Country:
Posted: Thu Nov 06, 2003 10:00 am Post subject:
1 more thing. Notice how the verbs mentioned above all have "ta" before the "kunai"? In short, the "ta" is a shortened version of "shitai" (want to). When you put the verb in a negative form expressing the desire of not wanting to....*blah*........ then you apply the "ta" for the "shitai".
The "kunai" makes it negative. Without the "kunai", you would say things like.......
"Tabetai" -I want to eat.
"Nomitai"- I want to drink.
"Kikitai"- I want to hear.
"Ikitai"- I want to go.
"Kaeritai"- I want to go home.
With the "kunai" please refer to the above examples.
Hope I explained this part clear enough for comprehension. I don't have much time to "think and type clearly". Sorry. Anyone let me know if you can't understand. I'll explain in detail later time and circumstance permitting.
Joined: 01 Oct 2003 Posts: 10291 Location: Matsuhama-cho, Ashiya-shi, Hyogo-ken, Japan Country:
Posted: Fri Nov 07, 2003 4:40 am Post subject:
arashinokoto wrote:
hey ahochaude.. if you have the time, why don't you have japanese lessons on a certain of the week.. then we can learn more from you too..
I'd love to help you guys out with lessons and all. But I don't think I can squeeze in the time for a lesson once a week. Besides, if I had the floor all to myself, I don't think that I would know where to begin and what to go over. Sorry! But I'll be happy to answer questions posted as I am doing now! I'm glad to see that I'm helping some of you out with your Japanese language comprehension.
Joined: 01 Oct 2003 Posts: 10291 Location: Matsuhama-cho, Ashiya-shi, Hyogo-ken, Japan Country:
Posted: Fri Nov 07, 2003 4:49 am Post subject:
velvet_ice wrote:
Thanks ahochaude. I agree with arashinokoto. If you can spare the time that is. I feel really embarassed posting so many questions, and I'm kinda lost now ... dunno where to start learning. Guess I should start from scratch
Don't feel embarassed posting questions. How else will you learn? You may be posting the same thing that someone else may be wondering. Only thing is that you have the "balls" to do it. Keep going at it and don't give up! Learn the things that you want to learn first. That way you won't lose your interest in learning the language. If you go by someone else's criteria, you may end up losing interest as I have in the past. I found that when I learn what I want to when I want to, it's more fun!
Joined: 12 Oct 2003 Posts: 15 Location: Singapore Country:
Posted: Thu Nov 13, 2003 1:05 am Post subject: jidoushi & tadoushi
Hi People,
I wonder if there is anyone who can enlighten me on this area. Recently I was taught on the existence of 2 types of verb jidoushi and tadoushi. However I still get really confused when I should use them.
These are what I know about them:
tadoushi is used with an object (particle 'wo' is used). It is needed when there is an intention on the action (like opening a door, etc). But I still cant get a full picture of its usage. Example, when a traffic police stop you, and you will have to stop your car, do you use tomaru or tomeru ??
In addition, jidoushi is attached to ~te imasu and tadoushi is attached to ~te arimasu. what about verbs which do not come in pairs, like aku/ akeru, how do I know when to use ~te arimasu or ~te imasu?
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum