Ichi Ritoru no Namida

[Wynter]

Rena-chan wrote:

http://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buku_Harian_Nayla clik that ..... is an indonesian, just see a pic..

Why are they copying the Japanese interpretation of the story instead of taking the Journal and coming up with their own?
_________________

Wanna trade? My Drama List (UPDATED: July, 2013)

[8thSin]

Reasons are obvious... Free, better story than what they can come up with, already proven to be a success.

Most of people in Indonesia or whatever probably haven't seen the original anyway

[Wynter]

8thSin wrote:

Reasons are obvious... Free, better story than what they can come up with, already proven to be a success. Most of people in Indonesia or whatever probably haven't seen the original anyway

Ahhhhhh... that makes sense. They're after money as opposed to artistic creativity.
_________________

Wanna trade? My Drama List (UPDATED: July, 2013)

[niko2x]

Wynter wrote:

Why are they copying the Japanese interpretation of the story instead of taking the Journal and coming up with their own?

isn't there some sort of copyright/plagerism law that is being broken as well??
_________________

Here's my Facebook page:
http://www.facebook.com/home.php?ref=logo#/kwan1?ref=profile

[Wynter]

niko2x wrote:

isn't there some sort of copyright/plagerism law that is being broken as well??

Totally... unless they've bought the rights...
_________________

Wanna trade? My Drama List (UPDATED: July, 2013)

[Jaegal_Maut]

Wynter wrote:

Why are they copying the Japanese interpretation of the story instead of taking the Journal and coming up with their own?

As indonesian I was really furious about this plagiatism , (once tried to send complain letter to the tv station, don't know how it went though), in really gets in my nerve that the production house didn't say anything about this film is based on 'ichi ritoru' or something, I tried to warn everyone of my friend to watch the original not the fake one..
this is a disgrace, its very shameful

If you're asking why? its easy because they want the easy profit from stealing the idea of well-known story.. drama in indonesia mostly aiming in profit not for art of film.. Thats one of the reason I dislike indonesian drama..
_________________

Me aka Proteos_Agna
[MMIF]Morning Musume Indonesia Fansub
[H!F]Hello!Fansub

[ruji]

Jaegal_Maut wrote:

As indonesian I was really furious about this plagiatism , (once tried to send complain letter to the tv station, don't know how it went though), in really gets in my nerve that the production house didn't say anything about this film is based on 'ichi ritoru' or something, I tried to warn everyone of my friend to watch the original not the fake one.. this is a disgrace, its very shameful If you're asking why? its easy because they want the easy profit from stealing the idea of well-known story.. drama in indonesia mostly aiming in profit not for art of film.. Thats one of the reason I dislike indonesian drama..

Like we've said, you don't have to be ashamed unless you were involved in the plagiarism. Don't feel bad.

[Wynter]

ruji wrote:

Like we've said, you don't have to be ashamed unless you were involved in the plagiarism. Don't feel bad.

Exactly.

Tho I understand your frustrations. I stopped watching Bollywood movies because of that.
_________________

Wanna trade? My Drama List (UPDATED: July, 2013)

[Jaegal_Maut]

Wynter wrote:

Exactly. Tho I understand your frustrations. I stopped watching Bollywood movies because of that.

ruji wrote:

Like we've said, you don't have to be ashamed unless you were involved in the plagiarism. Don't feel bad.

Thanks guys for your concern i'm deeply touched.. really appreciates it very much
_________________

Me aka Proteos_Agna
[MMIF]Morning Musume Indonesia Fansub
[H!F]Hello!Fansub

[monta]

Wynter wrote:

Totally... unless they've bought the rights...

one things for sure... they haven't

Jaegal_Maut wrote:

Thats one of the reason I dislike indonesian drama..

indonesian dramas are so crappy and all they do lately are just plagiarism

worse, Buku Harian Nayla is popular in indonesia. And one of the most indonesians horrible habbit, ignorance, when i tell some people that it's actually a plagiat, most of them just answer with... "so what?!"

Nayla was badly acted (Chelsea was okay i guess), and eventhough they copied the whole show, they made a different turn in the end making the show look really draggy...

But apllaus to Indosiar who just but the Ichi Ritoru no Namida lisence

. it will be airing in no time... february i guess.

Let's just hope the animo to watch it does not decrease just b/c of the crap called Buku Harian Nayle
_________________

[ThyGriever]

Rena-chan wrote:

http://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buku_Harian_Nayla clik that ..... is an indonesian, just see a pic..

great comparison

[Jaegal_Maut]

monta wrote:

indonesian dramas are so crappy and all they do lately are just plagiarism worse, Buku Harian Nayla is popular in indonesia. And one of the most indonesians horrible habbit, ignorance, when i tell some people that it's actually a plagiat, most of them just answer with... "so what?!" Nayla was badly acted (Chelsea was okay i guess), and eventhough they copied the whole show, they made a different turn in the end making the show look really draggy... But apllaus to Indosiar who just but the Ichi Ritoru no Namida lisence . it will be airing in no time... february i guess. Let's just hope the animo to watch it does not decrease just b/c of the crap called Buku Harian Nayle

That's good to hear that indosiar(another local tv station) bought the license, hopefully there will be much people who are gonna like the real ichi ritoru and erika too
But when its aired I think they 're gonna dub it.. zannen desu ne..
Yup agreed with you on chelsea acting although she has so-so kawaii face,
_________________

Me aka Proteos_Agna
[MMIF]Morning Musume Indonesia Fansub
[H!F]Hello!Fansub

[mumu2006]

Jaegal_Maut wrote:

That's good to hear that indosiar(another local tv station) bought the license, hopefully there will be much people who are gonna like the real ichi ritoru and erika too But when its aired I think they 're gonna dub it.. zannen desu ne.. Yup agreed with you on chelsea acting although she has so-so kawaii face,

first, i want to intoduce myself cause i am new here.
i am from indonesia especially from jakarta.
so yoroshiku onegaisimasu

about " Buku harian nayla"
i agree with you all, although i am indonesian. i am very shame about plagiarism in indonesia.

about indosiar ( another local t station) thanks for bought the license.
for RCTI (one of the broadcaster of buku harian nayla) ,you will lose your face because of being snatched of that plagiarism.

[Wynter]

Jhvx wrote:

Best dorama I've ever seen, it made me cry

Hai, I think it'll always remain #1 on my list of dramas.
_________________

Wanna trade? My Drama List (UPDATED: July, 2013)

[asiandramadownloads]

Wynter wrote:

Hai, I think it'll always remain #1 on my list of dramas.

Agreed! Every single episode was a tearjerker. I don't think I've ever cried so much watching a dorama. ><; hontou ni ichi rittoru no namida yo!
_________________

[hang-1988]

I'm new member.
I'm really not good at english .
I love this dorama very much .
I love Aya , and sawajiri , of course .
I watched this dorama 2 times and i can't stop crying , this dorama is so sad .
I loved episose 2 , it's when aya and asou take ganmo to her home , very funny .
ep 9 , when asou comes to aya's house , he asks aya's phone number and aya's dad ... oh , i like him , aya's father is so funny . and when he hears your daughter says aya is talking to asou kun , he ...
Oh i'm sure you all saw that , very sad but there are some funny something in this dorama .
I think i know how to live from now on , and i am sure you all understand what this dorama teach us " live on forever " , and I wish if there is a miracle , please , everyone never feels lonely .

[Wynter]

hang-1988 wrote:

I'm new member. I'm really not good at english . I love this dorama very much . I love Aya , and sawajiri , of course . I watched this dorama 2 times and i can't stop crying , this dorama is so sad . I loved episose 2 , it's when aya and asou take ganmo to her home , very funny . ep 9 , when asou comes to aya's house , he asks aya's phone number and aya's dad ... oh , i like him , aya's father is so funny . and when he hears your daughter says aya is talking to asou kun , he ... Oh i'm sure you all saw that , very sad but there are some funny something in this dorama . I think i know how to live from now on , and i am sure you all understand what this dorama teach us " live on forever " , and I wish if there is a miracle , please , everyone never feels lonely .

Hi, Welcome to the forum!

I'm glad the drama inspired you! There's something very uplifting and inspiring about it, for sure!

By the way, you're english is very good!
_________________

Wanna trade? My Drama List (UPDATED: July, 2013)

[The_Lyrics]

welcome to the forum.
and yeah this drama is very life changing

[slashersam016]

great drama.. of course Erika is really a great actress..
_________________

[thislove]

Hello everyone I'm new here. I really like 1 Liter of Tears, just like the title said I probably cried that much and even more while watching it. Very touching and sad drama. Aya was so strong