Fan reviews: Papa to Musume no Nanokakan

11 reviews · average 8.0 / 10

Reviews Page 1 of 1

Fun Comedy

9 / 10

mrsmith10 · 15 Jun 2011

This is really a delightful comedy. I couldn't stop laughing. The story was good as well. Kudos to Gaki and Tachi Hiroshi, they really played their parts well. The only complaint I had was that being only 7 episodes long it felt a little too short.

Relationship between father and daughter

8 / 10

ester_grace · 23 Dec 2010

The idea wasn't original but the story was great, about the relationship between father and daughter which was getting worse day by day..just like my father and me.

Better than expected

8 / 10

MonsterZero-65 · 19 Oct 2009

I was not very excited to see this because it is a very old plot line of a parent and child swapping bodies and living each others life. I started watching and could not stop though. This is really well done with some very funny situations and some fun acting too. If you need a good laugh you could do far worse than this little drama.

nothing special but it's still watchable.

7 / 10

weetzie_bat · 27 Apr 2009

cute. dorama version of freaky friday, only it's father-daugher so the dynamics are a bit different. but the actor who played dad was right on the money. gakky is her usual cute self. it's a short series, only 7 episodes.

Fun comedy with good acting

9 / 10

Jackykero · 28 Mar 2008

Indeed, as it was said above, the scenario lacks a bit in originality, but if you take it like a fun comedy, I think that it really does the trick. All actors are good, including Tachi and Aragaki who manage to preserve the comedy and still act seriously enough so that it is believable.

I really had a good time watching it. The pace was good, there was a good progression through the 7 episodes - I liked that they did not try to extend it to 10 or 11 episodes like they always do, this kept the pace going. I also like when a Dorama has a surprise at the end of each episode to make you want to start the next one right away

All in all a lot of good laughs that you should not overlook.

A Light, Fun Drama

7 / 10

Wynter · 11 Dec 2007

Will you remember this drama the day after you see it? Probably not. But it was fun while it lasted.

This drama has an interesting plot, but it was rushed and wasn't set up properly. The first episode is almost a joke in the way everything is slapped together.

However, the events that take place throughout the drama are very entertaining and I even found myself laughing out loud at some very hilarious parts. Because the drama is short, and because the content is light (and somewhat heart-warming), the drama carries enough substance to stimulate you while watching.

Tachi Hiroshi does a great job acting like a teenaged girl, and Aragaki Yui really surprised me with her acting ability. They were both convincing in their roles and made the drama a delight.

Great light hearted humour

10 / 10

Kugashira · 18 Nov 2007

Even though it had a rehashed plot, it was still a lot of fun to watch. Plenty of interesting and funny moments. Tachi and Aragaki gave really good performances. I usually don't give 10's but I really enjoyed this one.

Best Dorama!!

10 / 10

opospa · 17 Nov 2007

Thumbs up to both Tachi and Gakki!! And also the supporting actors and actresses. Tachi really acts like a high school student and Gakki acts so mature!!! And the drama teaches audience to appreciate our parents and parents should understand their children!! Bravo!!!

Cute, yet nothing special

6 / 10

Kirari Ililah · 21 Sep 2007

It's a nice, typical idea. As the relationship between father and daughter are usually a strong one, this drama touches base on the experience some people have with their own children. We don't know how our kids think, we don't know what they are doing, nor do we understand the things they understand in life. This story is nice on fulfilling a lost father-daughter relationship.

The only issue with the drama, other than that it was short, is that there wasn't too much of new material going on. There were funny parts and interesting parts, but nothing was really settled and the relationship between Kenta-senpai and Kome was typical and cheesy.

I have to say that for a drama it was ok, but as a way to attract the viewers, it did not do so well, the plot was quite predictable and there are many more things they maybe should have done. Though with the way the story/title is, it's hard to have room for improvement...

Great Drama!

9 / 10

m3lz · 11 Sep 2007

This was in my opinion the best drama for this season. The acting was great, ESPECIALLY the dad. Though the storyline may not have been the most "original" (like Freaky Friday but MUCH better), I thought that it was great! It kept me wanting for more, and I was sad that there were only 7 episodes! But all in all, a very entertaining drama!

Pretty Average

5 / 10

dekatrain · 31 Aug 2007

An average, pretty routine story with a recycled plot. Aragaki fans will see plenty of her, but this drama is one you'll forget the day after you finish it (as i'm struggling to remember it now!). Its not all bad - i think the dad did a reasonable job playing a teenage girl. You're not missing much.