Fye_D.Flowright wrote:
I'm not critisizing you dear :sweat: and don't feel like that again. Its normal for a new single to be critic by others whether its good or not. I'm saying like that because, as I mentioned in my previous post, Arashi deserved more than this, and I also thought this is an open thread and everyone is free to give opinion and discuss anything related to Arashi whether it is good or bad, as long as they didn't mention something that of course will ruin the future of Arashi. I'm not like the Step and Go song and PV, but I do think the Fuyu wo Dakishimete quite good song. If you go outside this forum, there's a lot of arashi fanz mentioned the same thing as I do, but they said it in same way as I think. ;)
So i'm a bit sensitive about my Arashi merchandise :p. Its rare for me to buy anything yet I picked this because I truly love the single thus indirectly am 1 of those who contributed to the amazing first day sales figure. And I'm proud to say I bought a copy. As I said before, the "hate" is louder here than the love. I'm just representing the S&G love.
The point of my initial reproached was because you came off (note: past tense) as dicrediting/downplaying/rebuting the obvious achievement from their amazing sales figure. In my opinion its a time for us to celebrate the ocassion rather than questioning wth the single was so successful. Its just natural for me to get all work up about it.. its 108679 for goodness sake. Rare even for a Johnny's (try searching for their past 1st day sales figures).
Arashi should get their due credits, not just generalizing them as Johnny's.. Claiming that its an ordinary Johnny's like achievement might not ruin Arashi future but, it still gives a whiff of negativity towards them imho. Its disheartening since they've worked hard to break the typical public perception of being "mere" idols.
And since this is an open thread, I'm free to criticize your critique. As I said before, I'm fine with fans not loving the single and am totally aware of the current fandom reaction towards Step & Go (song & PV). Unfortunately you missed reading the other theories I've suggested as to play along the trend of this thread on the reasons of S&G success (which includes Fuyu Dakishimete as one of the reasons. it in the previous page fyi.) Btw, jdorama is not the only place i've been loitering for Arashi crack fyi and I've been posting and lurking around Arashidom for quite awhile now, much longer than you presume I guess my dear ;).
I still stand by my opinion, the figures speaks lauder than all the talks/"hates".
sorry for not explaining the reasons of my rebuke clearly.
btw, what do you mean by
" Arashi deserved more than this"? Sorry, but I don't quite understand what were you refering to.