jdfan wrote:Summer snow is not even in the same class!
Look at these points:
Production - Look and feel of the dorama. Summer snow looked cheap!
Script - Yamato Nadeshiko is such a rollercoaster ride! SS is predictable!
Cast - Yamato Nadeshiko had the top notch Big Guns!
Music - Misia's title song was a big hit worldwide
Production - Both of em were good! Yamato had richer location! Bigger budget! Busy city with busy ppl.
Summer Snow location fits perfectly to its theme, a peaceful town where ppl know each other. Warm and cloudy climate.
Script - Actually Yamato was more predictable than Summer Snow! The poor wasn't that poor at the end and then happy endin- thing. Summer
Snow was sad and had its happy moments too.
Cast - Yamato had a bigger "star", Nanako herself. Sosuke only whined, not much of progress from him. Akiko Yada was overshadowed by Nanako! Liked Kasuya's part, hehe. Especially the scenes where he jumped on to that Hanabusa guy over the girl-issue.
Liked Domoto's role as a careful big brother of the two siblings. His additive method was quite old fashion. Yes, have to admit that Ryoko didn't do her best at actin. The other actors/actresses did a great job!
Music - You mean nationwide? Misia's song was ok, repetitive and got annoyed.
Summer Snow theme song was a true masterpiece! :applaud:
So much of warmt and feeling the singer ,Sissel, did for the series!
Both of em are good! Both series have its different meanings, Yamato about money and Summer Snow life!
Yes, I enjoyed watchin both of em!
BTW
the thread starter was talkin about "Merry Christmas in Summer" aka "Midsummer Snow", not Summer Snow.
hehe