bmwracer wrote:I'm not sure if this affects it, but doesn't WMP have a "fix video to frame size" setting somewhere? :headscratch:
You're correct, racer-dude. WMP does have that option, but unfortunately it doesn't correct the pixel ratio. Even if the frame size is correct, the ratio is still majorly distorted when played under Windows. On my XP machine, using WMP, a 480x480 MPEG-2/SVCD with a 4:3 ratio is displayed where the video is much taller than the width (visually, it should be the other way around). And, videos ripped with a 1:1 ratio, running under WMP, make everyone in the video look like midgets. Even with version 10, WMP still does this. Some people say it's the MPEG-2 codec that does this, some say it's WMP that's flawed, and others say Windows is flawed. Whatever the cause is, it's definitely not the capturer/ripper that's at fault, unless he chose something REALLY odd like PAL instead of NTSC. Video player software should be able to look at the configuration of the video file, and the configuration of the Windows environment, then make the adjustments automatically.
BSPlayer actually has the exact same problem as WMP, but at least there's algorithms in the software that'll allow the user to correct it on-the-fly. And under Mac OS X running these same kinds of files, I've never had these ratio issues.