thetenken wrote:Well, ATI used to suck. They have been a lot better in the last two years, ever since they released their Catalyst drivers (basically like NVIDIA's system of unified drivers). All ATI products older than two years aren't very good. As for good DVD burners, I've had good success with the Pioneer A05/105.
Coincidentally, it's the Catalyst drivers that are giving me trouble.
I right now use the ATI RADEON 9600 All-in-one card. Bought the card in early October 2003. I've done the following about a dozen or so times now:
- Install Windows XP Professional without any service packs or other hotfixes. Just your plain vanilla install.
- Install the Catalyst drivers 3.10 and the ATI multimedia software (8.1)
- Test, test, test... Things work so far.
The next steps sent the installation straight to heck...
- Upgrade to Windows Media Player 9.0
or upgrade to DirectX 9 (http://www.atitechnologies.com/support/faq/directx.html)
or install Service Pack 1 or later
or run Windows Update and have it start its first round of updates
- Kaboom!!!!!! Following things occur:
1) The ATI Scheduler, when run, crashed the recorder software.
2) Crashes InterVideo WinDVD Creator 2.0 when exporting a project to file (the ATI DLLs are the cause of the crash, according to the dump).
3) Crashes about two other video editing packages, same DLLs
4) InterVideo WinDVR 3.0 video capture is very choppy.
5) Weird enough, it conflicts with ANY PCI-based Ethernet card I tossed into the computer. Each time I boot up, blue screen of death. The ATI DLLs shown to be the cause of the crash. Ended up buying a USB-based Ethernet adapter as a work-around. The engineer says the ATI card I have eat up a lot of resources, with no way of overwriting the settings.
On each and every one of these problems, I spoke to a tier-2 or higher level engineer. And we were never able to solve the problems. I also tried two motherboards: ASUS P4SDX and the ABIT VP6. Same symptoms on both. Worked on this stuff for about 1.5 months before giving in.
SOLUTION: So right now, my capture machine is using the ATI card, with absolutely no patches/updates installed. And, I have it disconnected from my network to avoid any security issues seeing I can't patch the installation. In this configuration, I don't have a problem. This project is by far the biggest ass-kicking I've ever received after almost 20 years working with Microsoft Windows-based PCs.
Why do I still live with this card? It's still one of the best video capture cards on the market. I like the video quality this card cranks out. And it's cheap!
In a perfect world, I'd be using a Power Macintosh G5 with a good video capture card and iLife. But just the G5 alone is an arm-leg.
--- groink